
Summary: Congress writes tax laws, but the judicial branch has the final say in how those laws are applied. When taxpayers disagree with the IRS, they have several options for litigating a tax dispute. Choosing the right court and carefully considering when to pay tax can help taxpayers achieve the most favorable outcome for their circumstances.
What role does the judicial branch play in taxation?
A court decision can change how tax laws affect taxpayers, and not just in one case, but across the country. The rulings of the United States Supreme Court have the potential to impact the amount of tax due for taxpayers across the entire country. Congress writes the laws with their own intentions in mind, but the judicial branch decides how those laws apply in real-world situations. The U.S. Supreme Court has the final word on interpreting the Tax Code, although Supreme Court rulings on tax cases are not common. Most tax disputes begin in lower federal courts.
What are the two types of federal courts?
Federal courts that hear tax disputes generally fall into two categories:
- Article I courts are created by Congress. They include the U.S. Tax Court and the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
- Article II courts make up the judicial branch established by the Constitution. They include U.S. district courts, courts of appeals, and the Supreme Court.
The U.S. Tax Court
Congress created the Tax Court specifically to give taxpayers an independent place to challenge IRS determinations. Its roots date back to the Revenue Act of 1924, which established the Board of Tax Appeals within the executive branch. Overtime the court evolved:
- In 1942, Congress renamed the Board of Tax Appeals to the Tax Court of the United States.
- Under the Tax Reform Act of 1969, Congress repealed the Tax Court’s executive branch classification and established it as an independent agency that exercises judicial authority independent of the executive and legislative branches.
The U.S. Court of Federal Claims
Congress established the Court of Federal Claims as an Article I court through the Improvement Act. The intention was to increase the operational efficiency and effectiveness of the national court system by creating the claims court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
For taxpayers, the Court of Federal Claims provides another forum for resolving tax disputes. Distributing cases among multiple courts can also help manage caseloads across the judicial system.
Article III courts and judicial review
Article III of the Constitution establishes the judicial branch: the U.S. District Courts, Appellate Courts, and Supreme Court. These courts hear cases involving the Constitution, federal statutes, and federal treaties. They also have the power of judicial review, which lets them decide whether actions of Congress and the where the court can evaluate the actions of the executive branch are constitutional, even though the Constitution does not explicitly spell that power out.
What powers do courts have over tax law?
The judicial branch’s authority over federal tax matters comes from Article III of the Constitution. Article III establishes the Supreme Court which presides over the lower courts, then gives those courts authority to decide cases arising under the Constitution and federal law, as well as disputes involving the United States.
The authority extends to federal tax disputes in which the IRS Commissioner or the United States is a named party. Although Article III does not list specific tax-related powers, courts have long exercised several important responsibilities when interpreting and applying tax law.
The courts can:
- Interpret tax law: When a law is unclear, the courts decide how it applies to the facts of a case. That interpretation can guide how the law will apply in similar cases moving forward.
- Determine tax liability: The courts decide how much a party must pay or may be entitled to recover.
- Exercise judicial review: Courts can determine whether a law is consistent with the Constitution. This authority was established in Marbury v. Madison (1803) and applies broadly, including tax cases.
- Establish precedent: Once a court issues an official ruling, its legal reasoning may shape how courts address the same question in future disputes.
Why are these powers limited?
The Constitution intentionally divides authority among the three branches of government, so no single branch has complete power over the others. Congress has the power to create tax laws under Article I, the executive branch enforces those laws under Article II, and the judicial branch interprets them under Article III. This separation helps to maintain a system of checks and balances.
What tax litigation paths are available?
An important distinction must be made with how the courts intervene. Federal courts do not actively monitor the tax system or step into disputes on their own. Instead, they respond when taxpayers challenge how the IRS has interpreted or enforced a law through procedures established by Congress.
Disagreements are not unusual. Tax laws cannot anticipate every set of facts, so taxpayers and the IRS may reach different conclusions about how a rule applies. Effective tax planning therefore requires more than reading the law, it also requires applying the law to the taxpayer’s specific circumstance.
The main paths to judicial review include:
- Contesting a proposed deficiency before payment
- Paying the tax and filing a refund claim
- Seeking appellate or constitutional review
How can a taxpayer contest a proposed deficiency?
Contesting a proposed deficiency is the most common route of judicial intervention. Under a contest of proposed deficiency, a taxpayer who disputes an IRS determination may petition the U.S. Tax Court before paying the disputed tax, penalty, or fee.
Key features of this path include:
- Forum: the case is heard only in Tax Court
- Decision maker: a judge decides the case; there is no jury
- Payment timing: the taxpayer generally does not have to pay the disputed amount before filing
- Collection activity: assessment and collection are generally suspended while the case is pending
- Interest and penalties: they may continue to accrue and become due if the court ultimately upholds the liability

How does refund litigation work?
A taxpayer may choose to pay the disputed liability and pursue a refund. Paying first may help stop the accrual of interest and penalties on the unpaid. This route also gives the taxpayer the option of having their dispute heard before a jury in a forum with most favorable appellate and precedent authority to their position.
Under this method, the taxpayer must first file an administrative refund with the Secretary. If the claim is denied or the IRS does not act within the applicable period, the taxpayer may sue for recovery in one of two forums:
- U.S. District Court: The case is heard before a jury in one of the local districts nationwide, and the taxpayer may request a jury trial.
- U.S. Court of Federal Claims: A judge hears the case in a bench trial and there is no jury.
Both forums can hear refund suits after payment. Depending on the outcome, a successful taxpayer may also be entitled to interest on the refund.
How are tax court decisions appealed?
Appellate review allows a higher court to examine whether the lower court correctly applied the law based on the set of facts. Either party may begin the process by filing a notice of appeal.
- Decisions from the Tax Court and U.S. District Courts generally do not go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the taxpayer’s geographic circuit.
- Decisions from the U.S. Court of Federal Claims go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the federal circuit. While a case could potentially reach the Supreme Court, it is uncommon.
Across these levels, the U.S. court structure serves three primary purposes:
- Resolve disputes between taxpayers and the government.
- Interpret statutes when the meaning or application of tax law is unclear.
- Oversee administrative power by reviewing government action and enforcing constitutional limits.
How should a taxpayer choose a court?
A taxpayer can have their case be heard in a forum of their choice that carries the most favorable legal precedence. The decision depends largely on two considerations:
- When the taxpayer pays: A taxpayer may challenge a proposed liability in Tax Court before payment or pay first and pursue a refund in district court or the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
- Which precedent applies: Prior decisions influence how a court may evaluate similar legal questions. The Tax Court generally follows the precedent of the Court of Appeals, which means the legal precedence varies by geographical area. While the U.S. Court of Federal Claims follows the federal circuit precedence.
Forum choice can affect whether a jury is available, which appellate court will review the case, and which body of precedent may apply. Taxpayers should weigh these factors with their advisors before beginning litigation.
Why does the choice of court matter to taxpayers?
Each court serves an essential role in our government and provides a forum for tax disputes to be resolved and precedence to be established and followed. The Tax Court and Court of Federal Claims are both decided by judges, while a refund suit in a U.S. District Court may be heard by a jury. Decisions may then move to the appropriate Court of Appeals and, in limited cases, to the Supreme Court.
The choice of forum can influence payment timing, interest exposure, trial format, governing precedent, and the path of an appeal. As tax legislation and tax planning continue to evolve, understanding the structure and functions in place will empower taxpayers to decide on the most appropriate judicial forum for their dispute if one were to arise.
Case example: Kwong v. United States
Kwong v. United States illustrates how significant a court’s interpretation can materially affect a taxpayer. After paying the disputed amount, the taxpayer sought a refund in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims. The court concluded that the refund claim was timely and that the taxpayer was entitled to recover certain assessed interest and penalties, reaching a different interpretation from the IRS.
The case also shows why appeals matter: a higher court’s ruling can affirm, narrow, or reverse a trial court’s interpretation, with potential consequences beyond the parties involved. This case is still ongoing as it has been appealed by the IRS to the U.S. Court of Appeals, but the results will have a wide impact regardless of the final decision. If appealed again, the case could end up before the Supreme Court.
Final thoughts: what should taxpayers know about tax litigation?
The judicial branch serves alongside the legislative and executive branches as a key check on how tax law works in practice. If taxpayers disagree with the IRS, they have two main routes: contest the liability in the U.S. Tax Court before paying, or pay the tax, file the refund claim, and sue in a U.S. District Court or U.S. Court of Federal Claims. Though each route carries different trade-offs in timing, interest, juries, and precedent.
Missing a filing window or picking the wrong forum can be costly. Before you chose a path, Aprio’s tax controversy specialists can help you weigh your facts against each court’s rules and deadlines.