Why Does Every Employee Want Stock Options?
October 18, 2007
By Mitchell Kopelman, partner-in-charge of Tax
Why does every employee want stock options? Why do companies want to give out stock options?
The answer to both of these questions is simple: receiving and granting stock options can be easy. Stock options are a term most people who have worked for a technology company understand.
A stock option is defined as the right to purchase a specified number of shares of stock at specified prices and times. There are two basic types of options granted to employees: non-qualified stock options and qualified, or incentive, stock options (ISOs).
There were some predictions that private companies would slow down the issuance of stock options due to the new accounting rules (FAS 123R), which forced public and private companies to expense the “cost” of stock options. However, due to the broad acceptance of stock options as a compensation vehicle, private companies continue to issue them for a variety of business reasons. Other types of equity incentive plans commonly offered include:
- Phantom stock of stock appreciation rights – which most employees do not appreciate as they never receive an actual stock certificate
- Restricted stock grants – when an employer awards an employee stock, with certain restrictions, such as forfeiture of stock if the employee leaves before a specified date
Remember, do not back date option grants. There are legal, tax and ethical business reasons not to back date stock options or grants.
LLC and S Corporation Planning
Can an LLC issue options?
LLCs do not have an exact equivalent of incentive stock options. However, an LLC can:
- Grant options to purchase LLC units to employees. This has similar tax consequences to granting non-qualified stock options.
- Create a corporate member of an LLC and have that corporate member form a stock option plan and issue stock options to employees of the LLC.
- Create a management LLC entity which becomes a member of the operating LLC, then allocate or grant interests in the management LLC to the employees of the operating LLC.
- Form a phantom type equity plan.
Can an S-corporation issue stock options?
Yes, an S-corporation can issue stock options just like a C-corporation. Consider some of these planning ideas when managing a stock option plan for an S-corporation:
- Do not grant options to persons who are not U.S. residents or who can become non-residents in the future. If a non-resident of the U.S. exercises a stock option, your S-corporation would become a C-corporation overnight.
- Some companies have provisions in their S corporate stock option plans that only allow for the exercise of the stock option if the company has either a change in control and/or ceases to be an S-corporation.
Do stock options always result in long-term capital gain (LTCG)?
No. Most employees end up with ordinary income tax rates upon the sale of a company and pay out the vested options.
Most people want to receive stock options to share in the company’s growth. Also, people believe that they will only pay tax at LTCG rates. Currently, this rate is at an all-time low of 15 percent for federal income tax purposes.
In reality, over 90 percent of all private companies’ employees never end up with LTCG but, instead, end up with ordinary income treatment of their stock option benefits. Why?
Most people usually exercise and sell their stock options simultaneously in a buy-out situation, or if the company is public, it is usually relatively easy to do a simultaneous transaction on any day.
How to secure LTCG with options
- The only way for someone to achieve LTCG with an ISO is to exercise the ISO at least 12 months before the sale of the company. The sale must have occurred at least 24 months from the granting of the stock option.
- Most employees are not willing or able to buy the stock of their private technology company employer, unless they know for sure of a deal involving the purchase of the company.
- If an employee has ISOs, there are two levels of costs involved to exercise the options. First is the actual cost of the option, and second is the fact that the employee will likely be subject to alternative minimum tax (AMT) on the difference between the fair market value and the strike price when the shares are exercised.
- Even if people wanted to exercise their options and purchase stock, they can only purchase stock to the extent their options are vested.
For non-qualified options:
- Exercise the non-qualified stock option at least 12 months before the sale of the company, without concern to the stock grant date.
- If an employee has non-qualified options, there are two levels of costs involved to exercise. First is the actual cost of the option, and second is the fact that the employee is subject to tax on the difference between the fair market value and the strike price when the shares are exercised.
Planning around restricted stock or unit grants
- With restricted stock grants, the employee can elect, under Internal Revenue Code Section 83(b), to recognize the value of the stock as income upon receipt. The employee has 30 days to make and file the election with the IRS.
- Rather than an employee purchasing stock, the employee only has to pay taxes on the value of the stock.
- If the employee sells their shares more than one year later, they will achieve LTCG.
- Most people are afraid to pay tax now on a restricted stock grant. People are concerned that they will pay tax today and they may not have anything to show for this risk in the future. They then opt for options instead of a grant when offered.
- Usually restricted stock grants are of common stock. A company could raise capital multiple times and have debt holders too, who all have priority over the common shareholders.
- Employees may not have assets to risk paying the taxes on the value of the restricted equity grant.
- The pitfall of receiving a stock grant and not making the 83(b) tax election can become very costly to the employees. Typically, these shares have restrictions placed on them, and the restrictions lapse over time. As the restrictions lapse, the then-current fair market value of the equity become taxable as ordinary income. So each month or quarter, depending on the vesting schedule, the employee has to pay taxes on the fair value of the shares that become un-restricted.
An equity grant coupled with an 83(b) tax election is the single best way to secure LTCG treatment upon sale of the company. The upfront tax costs can also be minimized by entering into the transaction early enough in the evolution of a company that a valuation can justify a low price relative to a future exit.
Effective Jan. 1, 2006, companies are required to record an expense on their income statement for the “cost” of stock options. Many employees were concerned whether recording an expense would factor into the decision process of granting equity incentives to employees. Private companies are not overly concerned with the financial statement impact; however, there are a few planning considerations:
- A company can reduce the life of its stock option from 10 years to less, which can have an impact of lowering the cost recorded on the financial statements.
- A company can consider using non-voting common stock to reduce both the value of the strike price and the value of the shares, as well as the accounting expense to be recoded on the income statement of the company.
When providing for equity participation to your employees, it is important to share the company’s objectives with your advisors. The goals and objectives relate to both key members and other employees of the company. There are a myriad of tax, accounting, audit and business ramifications to the company and its employees, depending on the plan. Whether the plan covers domestic or international employees, there are solutions and various options (pun intended) to achieve a company’s incentive and reward goals.
About the Author
Mitchell is the partner-in-charge of Aprio’s Tax practice as well as the Technology & Biosciences group. He has been a partner since 1990 with Aprio, which is the largest Georgia-based tax, accounting and consulting firm. Mitchell works with companies in the software, gaming, clean tech, financial technology (FinTech), health care IT, processing, biosciences (biotech and medical device) and manufacturing industries. Whether a company is pre-revenue, starting up, growing or preparing for a liquidity event, Mitchell works with them to maximize their potential at each stage. He is known for promoting research, innovation and entrepreneurship by enabling companies to be successful, regardless of where they are in their business lifecycle.